Composition with Large Red Plane result screen
My rushed finish on Composition with Large Red Plane: 73.21%, and proud of it.

Copy the Mona Lisa. With a mouse. In three minutes. That is the whole pitch for Sloppy Forgeries, and it is exactly as impossible as it sounds, which is the point. Full disclosure before anything else: I am not good at being an artist. This game does not care. It grades every pixel you paint in real time and hands you a letter grade at the end, and somehow that turns being bad at art into the most fun I have had with a $15 game in a while.

Three Minutes, No Undo, No Mercy

The rules are brutal in their simplicity. The game holds 50 masterpieces, each one stripped down to a handful of flat colors. You get 4 to 6 colors, three brush sizes, and that is the whole toolkit. There is no undo and no fill tool. An accuracy bar rides along on screen, rising and falling with every stroke, and when the timer dies the game compares your attempt against the original, pixel by pixel.

My first real test was Composition with Large Red Plane, all bold blocks of red, yellow, black and blue. I focused so hard on getting those blocks perfect that I stopped watching the clock completely. When I finally looked up, I had to rush the rest, and the painting never actually got finished. It still scored 73.21% and a B, and the panic of that last scramble was the most fun I had all session. That is the moment Sloppy Forgeries clicked for me: the timer is not pressure on top of the game, the timer is the game.

It Gets Good When You Stop Trying to Be Good

Portrait of Madame X result screen
Portrait of Madame X, graded A at 80.75%. The less I cared, the better I scored.

Portrait of Madame X is where it came together. I stopped trying to make the painting perfect and started playing the way the game is clearly meant to be played, fast and loose, and the happily butchered result walked away with an A at 80.75%. There is a real lesson in that: careful gets you a B, confidence gets you an A.

The grades keep you honest the rest of the time. My American Gothic came back at 65.91% and a C, and looking at the faces I produced, the game was being generous. Then a simple red abstract painting handed me an S+ at 95.22%, which taught me the other rule of this game: the simpler the masterpiece, the better a non-artist looks.

American Gothic result screen
American Gothic, 65.91%, grade C. Grant Wood is rolling over, and honestly, fair.

A Whole Gallery to Work Through

The 50 paintings are grouped into collections, and there is always one more frame on the wall. I cleared the Minimalism collection with 2 stars in my first sitting and moved straight into Realism, which unlocked next. Every forgery you finish is saved into an archive, each painting carries its own Steam leaderboard, and you can watch a time-lapse replay of every stroke and share it as a GIF, which is exactly as incriminating as it sounds.

Collections screen showing grades so far
My gallery so far: an A, a B+, a C, and two paintings still judging me.

There is also a whole party side I have not tested yet. Sloppy Forgeries ships with online multiplayer through join codes for up to 7 friends, a local mode where two mice go head to head on the same computer, and random variants like Tiny Brush and Upside Down. I reviewed the game solo, so those modes are untested here, but my own notes after playing said I would keep playing if my friends pick the game up. The mode I wanted most is already in the box, waiting on them.

Runs Clean, No Fuss

Across my session the game ran smooth from start to finish. I never had to touch the settings beyond leaving VSync on and the frame cap unlimited, and I did not run into a single bug, crash or annoying quirk worth reporting. For a game built by a solo developer, that polish stands out.

The Catch

The honest drawback is length, at least playing solo. One collection was done inside my first hour, and while 50 paintings is a real catalog, a fast player will see most of what solo play offers across a few sittings rather than a few weeks. At $15 that is a fair trade for what is here, but go in expecting a game you pull out for a couple of hours at a time, and for friends once they grab it, not a forty hour commitment.

Verdict

Sloppy Forgeries is great fun, a game about failing beautifully at art you could never paint for real, and it gets funnier the worse you are at it. It is easy to learn, every round is over in three minutes, and the grading is just fair enough to make you chase one more painting. If you like art, laughing at your own drawings, or original ideas in small games, this one earns its price.

8
Great
A strong game with a few real drawbacks. Score out of 10.
Game: Sloppy Forgeries
Developer: Playful Systems (Jonah Warren)
Publisher: Playful Systems, ENJOYN GAMES
Price: $15
Platform: ROG Ally X (Steam), mouse required
Release date: November 13, 2026
Review copy: Provided by Playful Systems